Izinkan saya mengemukakan satu persoalan yang sukar saya jawab kepada seorang warga emas berusia 74 tahun yang permohonan kewarganegaraannya telah ditolak oleh Kementerian Dalam Negeri. Untuk tujuan perbincangan ini, kita namakan beliau Encik Tan. Walaupun Encik Tan dilahirkan di Singapura pada tahun 1952, iaitu sebelum kemerdekaan Persekutuan Tanah Melayu dan sebelum pembentukan Malaysia, beliau telah menetap di negara ini sejak berusia tiga tahun. Dalam erti kata yang sebenar, seluruh kehidupan beliau, identiti sosialnya, keluarganya, perniagaannya dan sumbangannya adalah berakar di Malaysia. Saya tidak faham bagaimana permohonan beliau di bawah Perkara 19(1) itu gagal diterima walaupun beliau selama ini telah melalui proses naturalisasi. Seorang abang beliau juga pernah menghadapi masalah yang sama iaitu tidak mempunyai kewarganegaraan, namun telah berputus asa untuk meneruskan perjuangan mendapatkan status tersebut walaupun saya cuba menggalakkan beliau terus merayu. Ha...
Before assigning blame, we should first be honest about the historical record. The Pakatan Harapan manifesto (Buku Harapan) was launched on 8 March 2018, when Anwar Ibrahim was still incarcerated. He only received a royal pardon and returned to active politics on 16 May 2018, after GE14 had already been won. Certainly, one can argue that as the current chairman and leading figure of Pakatan Harapan, Anwar should ultimately bear responsibility for the coalition's successes and failures. Leadership carries accountability. I have no quarrel with that. However, there is a significant difference between holding a leader accountable for the performance of his government and attributing personal authorship to promises that were conceived, drafted, and launched while he was still behind bars. To conflate the two is to blur the distinction between responsibility and authorship. It is like what I pointed out before this about Jalan Palestine , which was launched by Muhyiddin Yasin as...